Monday, September 16, 2019

The Destruction of the Country House.


Something I feel passionate about is the staggering loss of Britains large house since the first world war and up until quite recently. Since 1900 more than 1200 large country house have been destroyed and amongst them some 378 very important ones due to age or their architectural value.

Now many people would say ' but this only concerns the very rich' whereas was are talking about our heritage, our past, the thing we build our future on. One is six country mansions have gone in this period. One of the reasons the owners allowed this is due to inheritance tax or death duty. 

In 1910 it was 15% on taxable assets over 1,000,000 pounds but by 1949 it had gone up to 80% ! Left wing governements saw no reason not to impose this but when both a father and son died, say during the war, the taxes had to be paid twice! This was a period when great paintings and furniture were not fetching the prices they do today so selling off the assets to pay the taxes wasn't an option and institutions like the 'National Trust' either didn't exist as such or would only take on properties with an endowment to sustain them. Owners could just go ahead and demolish their homes, selling off the stone and trims for mere pounds.

In 1994 Sir Roy Strong, director of the Victoria and Albert Museum in London put on an exibition on ' The Destruction of the Country House', which was not only a brave move but it brought home to visitors just what had been lost of their heritage. Some of the surviving houses pale in comparaison to what was demolished.



I bought this book some time ago, you can still find it for between 60 and 150 pounds on Amazon.

As a teenager I used to play in a huge Georgian mansion near my village called Tarbat House, built in 1787 that had been empty for some time. It is actually grade A listed!  It had a huge hallway with a pair of marble fireplaces opposite each other and the plaster work around the top of the walls depicted stag and boar head in relief. The huge staircase would up to three floors and at its base sat a huge enamelled iron stove used to heat the stairwell. Each floor had suites of rooms behing green baize doors, all very Downton Abbey. The windows were shuttered and huge curtain poles still had their ornate brass rings on them that once held velvet drapes. There was even enormous mahogany wardrobes in the bedrooms, too large to be taken out in one piece. On the top floor there were the servants rooms with their brass beds and small wardrobes still in place. The walls still had their original wallpaper from the late 19th century and there was even some clothes in the cupboards. A small stair led up to the roof from where you could see the whole estate. The kitchens in a separate building still had their huge cast iron ranges and long kitchen tables where food was prepared in the past. This building was linked to the house by a corridor and the reason this was so was in case of fire mainly. 
Across from the house lay a huge walled garden for vegetables and fruit and on each corner was a pavillion in divers styles. One such building was Chinese in style and held the laundry and another was a thatched cottage for the gardener. This area was severly neglected and overgrown but there was still a lot of fruit trees.  The rododenrons were ten metres high and gorgeous.
I went back some years later to see that the lead roof had been stripped off and the stove and wardrobes and kitchen fitting had been stolen. the rain did it's best to rot the wonderful wood floors and slowly it fell in until some idiot decided to set it on fire. Today it is still standing and clad in ivy and on the 'Buildings at Risk register'. 
Below is Tarbat house as it was and Following the state it fell into.
This was how I last saw it.
I had not the courage to go back and see this terrible site.


I will add here a strange coincidence. On my recent flight to Scotland I sat next to a piano teacher who was going to the Ullapool to give a concert and when I said where I was from she said ' oh my nephew has a property near there'. OK what are the odds ! Yes it was Tabart House. Years of asking who owned it and there was the answer. She said that he had turned the kitchen quarters into a house, keeping the full ceiling hight so maybe he has some good taste but the house itself he cannot afford to restore, much is the pity. I used to fantasise as a kid that one day I would own it and restore it but the sheer cost in today's money would make that impossible.

Below is Rosehaugh House that stood near my home and was a most impressive house. It was demolished in 1959, the huge tower was the last to go and schoolchildren were invited to Watch.




A picture of its final days. Today it hardly seems possible especially when we know how much it costs to actually build in stone and have woodwork done specifically.


Here is Balintore Castle Scotland still standing and in the process of restoration by a lovely enthousiastic young man called David. You can follow his amazing Journey on his blog.


https://balintorecastle.blogspot.com/





Below are some of the lost houses that figure in the book, all gone now.



















The house below is absolutely vaste but that didn't save it from demolition. Some of these houses had up to 400 doors alone! One such house so resisted demolition that they had to dynamite it.




Some links.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Destruction_of_country_houses_in_20th-century_Britain


http://www.lostheritage.org.uk/index.html




12 comments:

  1. I agree that it is very sad to see these once elegant manors be destroyed. It is unfortunate that the government hasn’t come upon a way to save them, like helping the owners turn them into hotels so they can defray the costs of upkeep.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes but in context the destruction was either just after the first WW when so many families lost sons and fathers and then after the second WW many homes had been taken over by the war office and left in a terrible state with no money given to put them back in working order. After the war no one even considered this as a problem, they were still struggling with shortages, building was forbidden, materiels were super expensive when you could find them and so forth, sad is the reality !! huggss

      Delete
  2. I am 100% with you on the destruction of old homes but I guess the money to restore some, much less all, is astronomical and probably impractical and unfeasible. I am also a purist and find it heartbreaking when people buy old houses (even 80-100 year old houses) and renovate to modernise them. Australia’s heirtage controls tend to only protect the exteriors so the interiors get ripped out and ultra modern extensions added on the back. Shows like Escape to the chateau make me cringe - painting everything white? Adding art deco features? It’s not for me!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are so right, the things people do to their homes is criminal. I Watch a lot of house restoration programmes and the first thing they do is build horrendously expensive kitchen, no charm, like a restaurant, often jsut for a couple! There are thousands of chateaux in France falling down or Simply neglected. One recent chateau was going to be restored despite the owner not wanting to and it caught fire ! It went back to the 15th century! Most of these houses in France and in other countries could easily avoid disrepair if they paid people to live in them as guardians and stop the thefts and destruction. The Tarbat house I mentioned is a good exemple of foolish neglect. bigg huggss

      Delete
  3. Ohhhh, this just makes me want to cry! I knew that many magnificent country houses had been lost, often due to the death taxes, but I didn't know how bad it really was/is. I agree with you that it is a loss of culture and heritage and, quite simply, beauty. I think Prince Charles has a thing or two to say about it, as well.

    I am shocked by the death duties and cannot believe that they are not being lowered. If all that your parents have to leave you, when they die, is a toaster, then it should be yours without a problem. And if your parents leave you a manor house or a castle than it should equally be yours without a problem. I don't even know anybody with that kind of property, but I see absolutely no reason to begrudge anybody their inheritance.

    I, with no chance in hell of ever owning one of those houses, want them to remain. They are grand works of art, in my opinion. Looking back on it, you must feel so privileged to have been able to roam around in one of those houses, and, no doubt that makes it even harder to look at the house in its current state. Better to remember it as it was and not have the 'pictures' of memory in your head replaced by new ones. I will have to look at Tarbat house online a little bit more, as well as at the link which you provided. I think that this is a very interesting topic but one that makes me oh so sad!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes iris, over the years I have visited many abandonned houses and buildings and each time I feel so sad that we have turned our backs on our past so easily. The huge cost of building anything like we used to should ensure that we keep up these buildings and force the owners to sell them through compulsory purchase. I do realise that resoration costs are huge but the majority of these house would not have Fallen into ruin if they were kept up or guarded! When David Johnston tried to buy Balintore Castle the building suffered a lot in the 8 years it took for him to finalise the purchase and he could do Nothing about it. This is not specific the the UK as in the US a great many houses and chateaux have been left to ruin also. Poland has seen most of its chateaux gone during the war years too. huggsss

      Delete
  4. Realmente es muy,muy triste que por impuestos,el dinero que llena las arcas del estado,se pierdan estas maravillosas casas,que forman parte de nuestra historia y nuestra cultura.
    Un buen gobierno debería saber conservarlas de alguna manera,pero sabemos qué es lo único que mueve a los mandatarios tristemente...
    Besos.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sí, Pilar, es tan triste que el dinero tenga prioridad sobre la belleza y la cultura. Nunca podremos recuperar estas casas y lo que construimos hoy es tan terrible en comparación. No aprendemos por el pasado que parece.besososos

      Delete
  5. As in Joni Mitchell's song Big Yellow Taxi... Don't it always seem to go that you don't know what you've got till it's gone...I feel a true sadness that these magnificent structures have been destroyed never to be appreciated by the generations to come. Prince Charles has rescued one in Scotland called Dumfries House which included incredible furniture by Chippendale. Thankfully some owners are able to raise necessary funds by opening these homes to the public...death taxes should be reduced dramatically or eliminated all together. Cheers, Alayne



    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes I followed the Dumfries house thing, such a relief that all that specific made furniture was not sold abroad !! Strange that the death duty should impact the very type of person making and implimenting the laws ! It is tragic and the governement has a huge part of responsability in this terrible loss. hugggssss

      Delete
  6. It is absolutely heartbreaking but the government makes it very difficult to restore these old houses without personally going bankrupt.
    I have been watching restoration programs on youtube and new owners have so many hoops and red tape to jump through and often years of custom-work that they have to copy and/ or replace that it makes it cheaper and easier to demolish and build new.
    What REALLY annoys me though, is when someone buys an old decrepit historical home, guts it and updates it into a generic 21st century dwelling which retains little of the historical appeal of the original: quite infuriating!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know both versions are frustrating. I see people saving from destruction amazing buildings to be dictated each detail making the restoration almost impossible. These homes full of glass walls and ultra modern fittings are as impossible as the disnified versions we also see. You should follow Mr Balintore and his amazing dedication to Balintore castle with little money. huggsss

      Delete